A groundbreaking book when first published in Russia in , now Valeriy Zamulin’s study of the crucible of combat during the titanic clash at Kursk – the. Request PDF on ResearchGate | On Jan 1, , Martijn Lak and others published Demolishing the Myth. The Tank Battle at Prokhorovka, Kursk, July An. Demolishing the Myth has 49 ratings and 2 reviews. Luka said: Finally a book about Kursk battle from Soviet side! Book concentrates on epic clash on
|Published (Last):||4 July 2010|
|PDF File Size:||16.79 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||11.2 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
From time to time both sides’ AF are mentioned in passing e.
Zamulin describes how the Soviet High Command and the Voronezh Front had to cobble together quickly a defense of this line with already battered units, but needed to reinforce it with fresh formations at the expense of the counterstroke at Prokhorovka. To ask other readers questions about Demolishing thhe Mythplease sign up.
PDF Demolishing the Myth: The Tank Battle at Prokhorovka Kursk July 1943: An Operational Narrative
Craig rated it it was amazing Mar 08, Edgar R Zuniga-Ortiz rated it really liked it Jun 05, A groundbreaking book when first published in Russia innow Valeriy Zamulin’s study of the crucible of combat during the titanic clash at Kursk – the fighting at Prokhorovka – is available in English.
In and of itself this represents a monumental achievement, as reconstructing such a narrative involved researching actions taken and decisions made by a whole host of leaders on each side of the lines; as well as the placement and movement of a dizzying array of army’s, operational groups, corps, even down to the smallest tactical units. By recasting the struggle centered on Prokhorovka in such a way, Zamulin places the fighting into its proper context vis a vis the larger campaign of which it was the central part.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Zamulin assigns blame where he feels blame lies so Soviet commanders don’t get a free pass.
All of which informs and backs a study that among other things; deconstructs German objectives, how they were to be achieved, weighs the Soviet response, reveals in tremendous detail how the plans of the opposing army’s fared once battle was joined, answers questions that have long eluded past scholars, including one’s as basic as how many armored fighting vehicles clashed on the respective battlefields, and in that process brings much needed clarity to a moment in history long since obscured by decades old myths and rpokhorovka.
What I consider most serious flaw is that while the book ends with good analysis of Soviet performance and losses there is virtually no mention of air forces. Steven Mercatante rated it it was amazing Apr 01, James rated it really liked it Oct 01, Even though going well beyond just looking at events on July 12th near Prokhorovka this work is undoubtedly one whose bulk is devoted to a study of the II SS Panzer Corps attack into the Voronezh Front’s deeply echeloned defenses and the Red Army’s response to this attack.
Zamulin skillfully weaves reminiscences of Red Army and Wehrmacht soldiers and officers into the narrative of the fighting, using in part files batte to the Prokhorovka Battlefield State Museum.
Another are some smaller editing errors TK and DR divisions get switched, points are wrong described in text. Refresh and try again. This work stems from over two decades researching and studying the Second World War.
Examining the battle tthe primarily the Soviet side, Zamulin reveals the real costs and real achievements of the Red Army at Kursk, and especially Prokhorovka. The publisher, Helion, is to be congratulated for making it available to an Tqnk audience, not least of all given the excellent maps and photographic material which are included. If you are interested in this battle and wish to see more detailed analysis of Soviet performance as opposed to traditional German read it.
John Vasilakos rated it liked it Nov 22, Middlethought rated it it was amazing Aug 05, Why Germany Nearly Won not only prlkhorovka how close Germany actually came to winning the Second Prkkhorovka War, but also why Germany very nearly cemented a position of hegemony over the entire European continent by doing that which many consider to be its fatal decision; invading the Soviet Union in the summer of Glantz “Zamulin’s painstaking analysis definitively establishes the Soviet counterattack at Prokhorovka as the decisive event in the Battle of Kursk, and a turning point in the development of the Red Army.
Tim Mercer rated it it was amazing Oct 07, I hope the maps are good.
Demolishing the Myth, The Tank Battle at Prokhorovka Kursk, July | The Globe at War
One is absolutly attrocious maps. This has the added benefit of providing the reader with a more holistic look at how in reality a series of interconnected decisions and battles ultimately decided Citadel’s fate – rather than just the July 12th combat demolihing Prokhorovka itself.
A product of five years of intense research into the once-secret Central Archives of the Russian Ministry of Defense, Zamulin lays out in enormous detail the plans and tactics of both sides, culminating in the famous and controversial clash at Prokhorovka on 12 July The combat on this day receives particular scrutiny, as Zamulin tano to clarify the relative size of the contending forces, the actual area of this battle, and the costs suffered by both sides.
For armor enthusiasts few battles rank as high in terms of interest as the one fought in July of near the small Russian town of Prokhorovka; a struggle occurring during the Wehrmacht’s summer offensive against the Soviet held Kursk bulge in German lines.
Grega rated it it was amazing Aug 24, Open Preview See a Problem? Lists with This Book.
Tim rated it liked it Oct 29, Michael Byrne rated it it was amazing Feb 26, Zamulin is to be congratulated on writing a highly convincing and thorough analysis zt the tank battle at Prokhorovka. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.
Demolishing the Myth, The Tank Battle at Prokhorovka Kursk, July 1943
Carlos Sosa rated it really liked it Feb 02, Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically. An Operational Narrative by Valeriy Zamulin. Harrison, The Russian Review “It is very difficult to do justice to the level of detail provided in this study A former staff member of the Prokhorovka Battlefield State Museum, Zamulin has dedicated years of his life to the study of the battle of Kursk, and especially the fighting on its southern flank involving the famous attack of the II SS Panzer Corps into the teeth of deeply-echeloned Red Army defenses.
You are here Home. Preview — Demolishing the Myth by Valeriy Zamulin. He examines mistaken deployments and faulty decisions that hampered the Voronezh Front’s efforts to contain the Fourth Panzer Army’s assault, and the valiant, self-sacrificial fighting of the Red Army’s soldiers and junior officers as they sought to slow the German advance, and then crush the II SS Panzer Corps with a heavy counterattack at Prokhorovka on 12 July.
In particular, Zamulin has examined and, in tremendous detail, presented the crucial events occurring between July 4th and the 17th on the southern facing of the Kursk Bulge – where the Red Army’s Voronezh and Steppe Front’s defeated the best efforts of Germany’s Army Group South to meet Operation Citadel’s primary or secondary goals.
Scrupulously researched and supplemented by a number of excellent maps and photographs, this work will intrigue and inform serious students of the Eastern Front for years to come. Anthony Attard rated it liked it Mar 23, While the book itself is well written there are some glaring flaws.
Oct 27, Luka Novak rated it really liked it Shelves: